October 30, 2014

Learning Logic with a Smile -> Judge: Common sense is very uncommon. Lawyer : Yes, Sir. Judge: What did you...

This happened in the court of Justice Dipak Misra, Justice R. F. Nariman and Justice U.U.Lalit.

Justice Dipak Misra said to arguing lawyer, smilingly ,"Common sense is very uncommon".

Lawyer replied smilingly, "Yes, Sir."

Justice Dipak Misra quickly asked back smilingly, "What did you understand by this ?"

Everyone laughed and the lawyer replied, "Nothing."

Justice Nariman quickly came to rescue of lawyer by saying, "I too have understood nothing."

Again everyone laughed.

The arguments then once again resumed.

LOGIC

To say that "Common Sense is uncommon"  looks like saying "X is Not X"

But here the word "Common" has two different meanings in same sentence.

Another point is since "Common" and "Sense", two words are used, the logical format can be :

Xy is not X

Think over this.

I too have yet not understood.

Haresh Raichura
30/10/14