March 4, 2012

Why some lawyers felt that Judges Should Not See Amir Khan's Film GAJNI ?


Two Lama discussed effect of Amir Khan's Film GAJANI on a Judge

In the mountains of Tibet
 Elder lama taught younger lama
Benefits of being stupid
And then suggested him
To ask three most stupid questions

“Are Judges human beings?
Do they have emotions?
Do they see Amir Khan’s films?”

Younger lama asked three questions
Which he considered
Most stupid questions

Elder Lama replied,
“Yes, the Judges too are human beings
they too have emotions and failings,
and they too see films of Amir Khan”

“Then why lawyers are saying that the Judges
should not see film Ghajni
which collected more than 200 crores
from people in two weeks?”
asked younger lama

“Because many people who saw this film
started suffering from
‘Short Term Memory Loss’ disease”
replied Elder Lama

“What is this
Short Term Memory Loss disease?”
Asked younger lama.


Elder Lama explained,

“In this disease,
a person retains his long term memory,
but he cannot hold any new information
for more than fifteen minutes
in his short term memory.

"After 15 minutes,
He goes blank
And he has to be retold everything again”

‘Why lawyers consider it
inadvisable for judges to see this file?”
younger Lama asked

Elder Lama replied,

“A  husband –wife had gone to see this move,
after they came out from cinema hall,
husband asked his wife,
‘Who are you? I don’t remember you’

A person who had taken a big loan,
Forgot that he had ever taken any loan
He asked his creditor, 
‘Who are you? I don’t remember you’

A Judge who had gone to see this film
Reported Short Term Memory loss”
Elder Lama explained

‘What happened to the judge?”
asked younger lama

‘Next day judge declared in court
that he is suffering from short term memory loss
and he cannot remember a case
for more than 15 minutes

‘He requested both side lawyers
to finish their arguments
in 13 minutes so that he can have
two minutes for dictating judgement”

“And what happens if lawyers
continue to argue for more than 15 minutes?”
asked younger lama

“After fifteen minutes,
the mind of judge goes blank
and he begins to look blankly around him
and then he asks court-master,

‘Who am I?
Who are these lawyers?
Why are we here?’
   
After court master explains him the situation,
And tells him that he is Judge who is hearing a case.

He then asks lawyers,
‘Is this a civil case or a criminal case?’

And the lawyers have to re-start again”
Elder lama explained the disease of the Judge

And also explained why lawyers think
that Judges should see this film.

Haresh Raichura
(An imaginary work)