January 5, 2014

False Argument: "If I am convicted in court, I'll quit"

The politicians and other people in public life often issue statements that "The allegations are false, prove it in court. If I am convicted by court I'll quit."

This is a false argument for two reasons:

1) Once a person is convicted, he has no options. He is taken into custody. He is forced to quit. So the argument that "If I'll be convicted, I will quit" is an argument which has no weight.

2) "If I am convicted in a court of law"... This rider implies that it will take about 5 years or more to finally decide a case. "So till then I am not going to quit even if I may be guilty". This is what is being argued.

In my view both these argument does befit a person holding high public office.

Haresh Raichura
1024